Saturday, November 21, 2026
Hawai'i Free Press

Current Articles | Archives | Search

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Hawaiʻi County mayor should veto misguided bill to ban paid parking

By Grassroot Institute @ 7:39 PM :: 70 Views :: Hawaii County , Land Use, Small Business
 

Hawaiʻi County mayor should veto misguided bill to ban paid parking

by Jonathan Helton, Grassroot Institute, November 20, 2026

The Hawaiʻi County Council passed a bill on Nov. 6 that aims to prohibit new paid parking facilities throughout most of the island — but Mayor Kimo Alameda should not sign the measure or allow it to become law. 

Bill 154, Draft 2 would remove paid parking facilities as a permitted use in all zoning districts except for the commercial downtown Hilo district. Existing facilities could continue operating but would be treated as nonconforming uses, which could turn routine maintenance into a bureaucratic headache. 

The stated intent of the bill is to promote efficient land use and reduce automobile dependence. However, it is unlikely to accomplish those goals and could harm small businesses. 

Worse yet, the bill fails to address a true driver of inefficient land use: minimum parking mandates. 

Parking requirements push buildings apart, preventing the construction of walkable, mixed-use areas. Even businesses that do not need large amounts of parking must construct it as a condition of their building permit. 

The county’s recent downtown Pahoa rezoning recognized these flaws and rightly exempted the area from parking minimums. 

Instead of addressing parking minimums countywide, the Council has targeted the wrong culprit. Paid parking can actually be beneficial because it signals desirability to county planners and landowners. When consumers are willing to pay to park, it shows they believe the nearby shops or restaurants are worth the cost. 

Furthermore, desirable areas make prime targets for future investments, such as housing, new bus stops or commercial real estate, that could enable more residents to walk or use public transportation to access those amenities. 

Paid parking also promotes turnover, which keeps spaces open for other drivers. Free parking, on the other hand, increases demand because drivers have no reason to quickly move their vehicles. Additionally, residents could choose to use other forms of transportation to avoid paying for parking.

Bill 154 wouldn’t just remove those inherent checks and balances. It would make it harder for small businesses to adapt to changing circumstances around them.

Hilo resident Vincent Tai highlighted this issue in testimony he submitted against the bill. He said he owns land that is suitable for affordable housing but hasn’t found a developer yet, so he leases it as a paid parking lot to gain additional income. Future property owners would not be able to do that if Bill 154 becomes law. 

The Japanese Chamber of Commerce also submitted testimony opposing the bill, arguing that “by prohibiting new privately operated commercial parking lots and garages, Bill 154 would effectively remove opportunity to create additional parking supply, further constraining an already limited resource of parking spaces.” 

Indeed, reducing competition between private parking providers could increase prices. If no new facilities can be constructed, existing providers would have a monopoly and could raise rates. 

Another downside to the bill is that it would create uncertainty for businesses that need to repair their paid parking facilities or even replace them after a disaster. The County’s zoning code about nonconforming uses primarily addresses buildings, raising questions about how existing commercial parking would be treated. 

It is possible that even adding a single parking space to an existing facility would become illegal without obtaining an arduous special use permit or variance. 

As the Hawaii Island Chamber of Commerce pointed out, the Council could adopt a less restrictive approach that doesn’t involve “eliminating a potential private-sector solution to an existing community need.” 

Rather than meet its stated goals, this bill is likely to exacerbate existing parking issues across the island. Mayor Alameda should send it back to the drawing board. 

 

Comments