A New Sheriff in Town
by Tom Yamachika, President, Tax Foundation Hawaii
For a while now, Governor Green has been saying that he is going to shake up his Cabinet for his second term. About half of the current Cabinet will stay. The other half will be new. According to reporting by Hawai’i Free Press, the current Director of Taxation will not be reappointed, so there will be a new sheriff in town.
One of the problem areas often pointed out is difficulty in getting past due taxes paid. In a briefing to the House Finance Committee in January, for example, it was pointed out that the Department’s receivables totalled $1.58 billion.
At times it has been tough to work with the Department’s Collection Division, as the Hawaii State Tax Watch Doggie found out:
Doggie: Hi, I wanted to get an update on my offer to compromise my back taxes.
Collector: We aren’t able to consider your offer.
Doggie: Why not? I submitted my financial condition form, bank statements, and other supporting information.
Collector: That was three months ago. Your information is out of date. We need current supporting information.
Doggie: Okay, I came prepared. Here are my most recent three months of bank statements.
Collector: Great!
Doggie: So when can I get a response to my offer?
Collector: We consider applications in the order they are received. You’ve completed your application today, so we need to consider the applications that came before yours first.
Doggie: How many applications are in line?
Collector: 16,384. Please contact me in three months. Your application should have moved up the list by then.
(This scenario is, of course, fictional, although it does have elements of actual taxpayer experience. And no, the Doggie does not in fact owe back taxes.)
Another big problem has been exemplified by the Hawaii Taxpayer Bill of Rights, another important document, which was criticized in an op-ed published in Civil Beat in January 2026. The author’s point was that a key promise made in the document — a promise to use forced collection actions later rather than sooner — contradicted the Department’s actual practice.
Documents that the Department publishes for taxpayers to rely on should not be simply “aspirational goals,” but need to be binding on the Department. It is simply unfair when a taxpayer relies on a published document and an auditor later says, “No, we are not following that document. It is not a reasonable interpretation of the law, and you should have known that from reading the law and the court decisions interpreting it.” Department staff might know about the law text and the court decisions because that is their job. Ordinary taxpayers don’t. They rely on the Department to make sense of the law so they can comply with it.
We look forward to seeing the new sheriff in town. And, whoever you are, you might want to pay some attention to these issues (there are others but let us start somewhere.)