Monday, February 24, 2020
Hawai'i Free Press

Current Articles | Archives

Friday, April 05, 2019
9th Circuit: City Can Only Enforce Sleeping Ban if Shelter Available
By Robert Thomas @ 10:48 PM :: 3196 Views :: Homelessness


Ninth Circuit: Local Governments Cannot Enforce 24/7 Ban On Sleeping Or Camping On The Sidewalk If Nowhere Else To Go

by Robert Thomas, InverseCondemnation, April 3, 2019

As we've noted before, the growing homeless and "urban camping" situation seems to be getting worse, and in our perception is reaching the point of being intractable. A trip down the sidewalk of any major city  -- if you dare, particularly in the west -- will confirm. And there are no easy answers, except maybe "get used to living with it." Nor is there a consensus whether the law can do anything to remedy the problem.  

The Ninth Circuit's latest foray into this area, this order denying rehearing and rehearing en banc of a panel opinion in a case out of Idaho, confirms. The case is a challenge to Boise's ordinance under the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishments. The panel concluded that the city could not prosecute people for sleeping outside on public property because they have nowhere else to go. Until the city provides them a bed, it can't try to give them a bed (in a jail).

The order is followed by an amended panel opinion, a dissent from the denial of rehearing, an opinion concurring in the denial (arguing that such "dissentals" are disfavored), and a second dissent which focuses on the Eighth Amendment. And somewhat heated words (the expected Red Lily quote, see page 38) and pictures (as above, page 25) from the usually-staid black-robed law lords. 

So what's the law in the Ninth Circuit now, or until the Supreme Court weighs in? Who knows.

We'd take a deeper dive into the opinions to try and get some sense of what this means for Honolulu's "sit/lie" ordinance, which says no to sidewalk camping during certain hours of the day. But this is a busy time on our work schedule in the real world, and we have business to attend to. 

So here's the bottom line in the case. A panel of the Ninth Circuit has ruled thusly:

We consider whether the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment bars a city from prosecuting people criminally for sleeping outside on public property when those people have no home or other shelter to go to. We conclude that it does.

Slip op. at 38. Because sleeping is a basic human need, and you have to do it somewhere. If a homeless person has nowhere else to sleep, the city can't prosecute them for doing it on the street. Jones v. City of Los Angeles, 444 F.3d 1118 (9th Cir. 2006) resurrected.

One of the challenged Boise ordinances prohibited sleeping on the streets "at any time." The other was silent about the time, but could be read to prohibit it always. Does this mean ordinances which criminalize sleeping on the sidewalk only during certain parts of the day -- such as Honolulu's -- are not subject to the ruling? It's an argument, for sure. 

And what does the panel's rationale mean for other basic human needs like taking a dump in the street? One of the dissents focused on that: "Moreover, the panel’s reasoning will soon prevent local governments from enforcing a host of other public health and safety laws, such as those prohibiting public defecation and urination." Slip op. at 10 (M. Smith, J., dissenting).

And with two separate dissents from the denial of rehearing en banc (and that concurring opinion decrying such "dissentals"), this case may not be over, and seems teed up for a cert petition. 

Here's more on the decision:

Here's more on what we've posted with our own thoughts on the subject:

No easy answers for sure. 

PDF: Order Denying Rehearing En Banc, Martin v. City of Boise, No. 15-35845 (9th Cir. Apr. 1, 2019)

June, 2018: Caldwell: Outlaw Homeless Blocking Public Facilities While Refusing Shelter Space


TEXT "follow HawaiiFreePress" to 40404

Register to Vote


808 Silent Majority

808 State Update AM940


ACA Signups Hawaii



Alliance Defending Freedom

Aloha Life Advocates

Aloha Pregnancy Care Center

American Council of Trustees and Alumni

American Mothers of Hawaii



Antonio Gramsci Reading List

A Place for Women in Waipio

Astronomy Hawaii

Audit The Rail

Ballotpedia Hawaii

Better Hawaii 

Blaisdell Memorial Project

Broken Trust 

Build More Hawaiian Homes Working Group

CAFR Hawaii

Castaway Conservative

Children's Alliance Hawaii

Children's Rights Institute

Christian Homeschoolers of Hawaii

Citizens for Recall

Cliff Slater's Second Opinion

Coffee Break

CSIS Pacific Forum

DAR Hawaii

DVids Hawaii

E Hana Kakou Kelii Akina

E Māua Ola i Moku o Keawe

Farmers For Choice Hawaii


Fix Oahu!

Follow the Money Hawaii

Frank in Hawaii

Front Page Magazine

Frontline: The Fixers

Genetic Literacy Project

Get Off Your Butts!

God, Freedom, America

Grassroot Institute

Hawaii Aganst Assisted Suicide

Hawaii Aquarium Fish Report

Hawaii Aviation Preservation Society

Hawaii Catholic TV

Hawaii Christian Coalition

Hawaii Cigar Association

Hawaii Coalition Against Legalized Gambling

Hawaii ConCon Info

Hawaii Credit Union Watch

Hawaii Crime Victims' Rights

Hawaii Crop Improvement Association

Hawaii Debt Clock

Hawaii Defending Marriage

Hawaii Defense Foundation

Hawaii Families for Educational Choice

Hawaii Family Advocates

Hawaii Family Forum

Hawaii Farmers and Ranchers United

Hawaii Farmer's Daughter

Hawaii Federalist Society

Hawaii Federation of Republican Women

Hawaii Firearm Community

Hawaii Fishermen's Alliance

Hawaii Future Project

Hawaii Gathering of Eagles

Hawaii History Blog

Hawaii Homeschool Association

Hawaii Jihadi Trial

Hawaii March for Life

Hawaii Meth Project

Hawaii's Partnership for Appropriate & Compassionate Care

Hawaii Public Charter School Network

Hawaii Rifle Association

Hawaii Right to Life -- Big Island

Hawaii Right to Life -- Oahu

Hawaii Shield Law Coalition

Hawaii Shippers Council

Hawaii Smokers Alliance

Hawaii State Data Lab

Hawaii Together

Heritage Foundation

HI Coalition Against Legalized Gambling



Hiram Fong Papers

Homeschool Legal Defense Hawaii

Honolulu Homeless Crisis

Honolulu Navy League

Honolulu Traffic

Horns of Jericho Blog

House Minority Blog

House Republican Caucus YouTube


Hump Day Report

I Vote Hawaii

If Hawaii News

Imua TMT

Inouye-Kwock, NYT 1992

Inside the Nature Conservancy

Inverse Condemnation

Investigative Project on Terrorism

Iowa Meets Maui

Jackson v Abercrombie

Jihad Watch

Judgepedia Hawaii

July 4 in Hawaii

Kahle v New Hope

Kakaako Cares

Kau TEA Party

Kauai Co GOP

Keep Hawaii's Heroes


Land and Power in Hawaii

Legislative Committee Analysis Tool

Lessons in Firearm Education

Lingle Years

Malulani Foundation

Managed Care Matters -- Hawaii

Malama Pregnancy Center of Maui

Mauna Kea Recreational Users Group

Middle East Forum--The Legal Project

Mililani Conservatives for Change

Military Home Educators' Network Oahu

Missile Defense Advocacy

MIS Veterans Hawaii

Muslim Brotherhood in America

NAMI Hawaii


National Christian Foundation Hawaii

National Parents Org Hawaii

National Wind Watch

New Zeal

NFIB Hawaii News

No GMO Means No Aloha

Northwest Economic Policy Seminar

Not Dead Yet, Hawaii

Now What I Really Think

NRA-ILA Hawaii

Oahu Alternative Transport

ObamaCare Abortion Hawaii


OHA Lies

Opt Out Today

Pacific Aviation Museum

Patients Rights Council Hawaii

PEACE Hawaii

People vs Machine

Pritchett Cartoons 

Pro-GMO Hawaii


Rental by Owner Awareness Assn

Republican Party -- Hawaii State

Research Institute for Hawaii USA

Rick Hamada Show

RJ Rummel

Robotics Organizing Committee

School Choice in Hawaii

SIFE Remington

SIFE W. Oahu 

Sink the Jones Act

Smart About Marijuana--Hawaii

St Marianne Cope

State Budget Solutions Hawaii

State Policy Network

Statehood for Guam

Tax Foundation of Hawaii

The Harriet Tubman Agenda

The Long War Journal

The Real Hanabusa

Time Out Honolulu

Trustee Akina KWO Columns

Truth About Trade & Technology - Hawaii

UCC Truths

Union Members Know Your Rights

US Tax Foundation Hawaii Info

Valor in the Pacific

VAREP Honolulu

West Maui Taxpayers Association

What Natalie Thinks

Whole Life Hawaii